Mobilisation of a Judge for Military Service Does Not Terminate the Constitutional Guarantees of His or Her Status: Constitutional Court of Ukraine Delivers a Decision
On 4 November 2026, the Second Senate of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, at its plenary session, considered the case upon the constitutional complaints by Hryhorii Syvukhin and Taras Andreychuk concerning the constitutionality of Article 119.3 of the Labour Code of Ukraine (hereinafter, the “Code”) (case concerning guarantees of judicial remuneration for judges who have temporarily acquired the status of military personnel) and delivered Decision No. 14-r(II)/2026)
The Judge-Rapporteur in the case – Oleksandr Vodiannikov.
Having examined the issues raised in the constitutional complaints, the Court declared Article 119.3 of the Code constitutional, while establishing that its application by courts as grounds for terminating the payment of judicial remuneration to judges called up for military service during mobilisation was based on an interpretation that is inconsistent with the Constitution of Ukraine.
The constitutional complaints were prompted by amendments to Article 119.3 of the Code introduced by the Law of Ukraine No. 2352–IX dated 1 July 2022, which, as of 19 July 2022, abolished the guarantee of preserving average earnings for employees called up for military service. Applying this provision to judges serving in the military during mobilisation, the courts of appeal concluded that there were no grounds for paying them judicial remuneration.
In considering the case, the Court proceeded from the premise that judicial remuneration is both a subjective property right of a judge and an objective guarantee of the independence of the judiciary. It constitutes an integral element of the constitutional status of a judge and, by its legal nature, differs from an employee’s salary, the payment of which is governed by labour legislation. The Court emphasised that guarantees of judicial independence are not personal privileges of judges but are intended to ensure everyone's right to judicial protection by an independent and impartial court.
Further developing its legal position on the substance of Article 130.2 of the Constitution of Ukraine, the Court noted that all matters relating to the determination of the amount, conditions and grounds for the payment of judicial remuneration, including its reduction, suspension, termination or replacement with another payment, must be regulated exclusively by the law on the judicial system and the status of judges. This constitutional requirement is addressed not only to the legislature but also to the courts: they may not derive from other laws grounds for terminating or reducing judicial remuneration where no such grounds are provided for by the law on the judicial system and the status of judges.
The Court emphasised that, in the absence of a specific provision in the Law of Ukraine “On the Judicial System and the Status of Judges” No. 1402–VIII dated 2 June 2016, as amended (hereinafter, the “Law No. 1402”), providing for the termination or suspension of judicial remuneration, its reduction or replacement with another payment, the general regime governing its payment remains applicable. The absence of such a provision cannot be interpreted as authorising the termination of a constitutional guarantee.
The Decision underscores that the constitutional status of a judge is continuous throughout the entire period during which the person holds judicial office. The call-up of a judge for military service during mobilisation and the temporary release of that judge from the exercise of his or her judicial functions do not terminate his or her status as a judge or the constitutional guarantees attached to that status.
The Court also drew particular attention to the interplay between labour legislation and legislation governing the judicial system. Provisions of labour legislation may apply to judges; however, such application is subsidiary (supplementary) in nature and may serve only to safeguard the constitutional status of a judge. They cannot constitute legal grounds for restricting or terminating guarantees that form part of a judge's constitutional status.
Having analysed the substance of 119.3 of the Code, the Court concluded that the removal, in 2022, of the provision guaranteeing the preservation of average earnings for employees called up for military service could not alter the legal regime governing judicial remuneration. Since Law No. 1402 did not provide for the termination of its payment on the grounds that a judge had been called up for military service during mobilisation, there were no legislative grounds for such termination.
The Constitutional Court of Ukraine established that, in the applicants' cases, the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal had extended the application of Article 119.3 of the Code to legal relations concerning the payment of judicial remuneration, which the Constitution of Ukraine assigns exclusively to the scope of regulation of the law on the judicial system and the status of judges. Such an interpretation is inconsistent with Article 130.2 of the Constitution of Ukraine, read in conjunction with Article 126.1 thereof.
Following its consideration of the case, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine declared Article 119.3 of the Code constitutional in terms of its compliance with Article 130.2 of the Constitution of Ukraine. At the same time, the Court established that this provision, as applied in the rulings of the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal dated 14 April 2025 in the case of Hryhorii Syvukhin and 19 August 2025 in the case of Taras Andreychuk, had been interpreted in a manner inconsistent with the Constitution of Ukraine.
The Court separately emphasised that its conclusion does not concern the amount of financial support payable to a judge during military service, but rather compliance with the constitutional requirements governing the manner in which judicial remuneration is regulated by law.
The Decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine is binding, final and may not be appealed.
The text of the Decision will be published on the official website of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on 5 November 2026.
